
The Economics of Embedded Payments
Here’s how SaaS platforms can assess embedded payments economics, from transaction mix and costs to merchant support and operational effort.
Also Listen On:
TL;DR
- Growing processing volume doesn’t automatically mean your payments program is becoming more profitable. Review revenue, costs, and what the program contributes after expenses.
- Transaction mix, merchant changes, pricing, and program structure can all affect payments economics as a SaaS business grows.
- Include the operational work of onboarding and supporting merchants in your assessment, and pursue changes when the expected benefit justifies the cost and effort.
- Weigh potential improvements against the development time and resources required; a small return may not justify the investment.
- Consider how pricing changes could affect merchants and the competitiveness of your payments offering.
- Review your program regularly with your payments provider, and involve the people who understand its financial, operational, and merchant impact.
Episode Transcript
Shannon: Hey, everyone. Welcome back to Payment Pulse. I’m Shannon, and Michelle is here with me today. Hey, Michelle!
Michelle: Hello, hello, Shannon. How’s it going?
Shannon: It’s going good. It’s going good. We’ve spent a lot of time on this podcast talking about growing embedded payments programs, so things like getting merchants onboarded, increasing adoption, and growing revenue.
But today, we’re going to look at something a little different. So what happens when your payments program is growing, but you’re not really sure whether you’re getting as much out of it as you could?
Michelle: Yeah, I think that’s something a lot of SaaS platforms could overlook. If you’re bringing on merchants and your processing volume keeps going up, you’re probably feeling pretty good about the program, but you may not be spending much time looking at what you’re actually earning from that volume.
Shannon: Yeah, I can understand that. If payments revenue is growing, it might not seem like there’s anything you need to change, but there could be opportunities you’re missing, especially if your business has changed quite a bit since you launched payments.
Michelle: Or your costs may have changed and you haven’t really looked at why. I think once payments become a meaningful part of your business, it’s worth taking a closer look at the numbers behind that growth.
Shannon: Yeah, so let’s get into that. If your payments volume is growing, what should you be paying attention to beyond the volume itself?
Michelle: Yeah, so I’d wanna understand how much the payments program is contributing financially. Processing volume is one number, payments revenue is another, and what you’re actually keeping after costs is something else. Those numbers don’t necessarily grow at the same rate.
Shannon: And depending on how your program is structured, the economics can look pretty different. So some platforms have a revenue share arrangement, some might have more control over pricing and monetization. So before you start looking for ways to improve anything, you need to understand how your current model works.
Michelle: And how it’s performing today. If your processing volume has increased significantly over the past few years, I’d wanna compare what you’re earning now with what you were earning before. Have your margins changed? Are you serving different types of merchants? And are your costs increasing?
Shannon: Yeah. Something else that I would want to understand is whether we’re looking at the full picture, because processing costs are one part of it, of course, but there are most likely other expenses involved in managing the program, and we’ll get into those in a little bit here.
Michelle: Yeah, and I think it’s worth pointing out that you may look at all of this and find that your program is doing really well, but at least you’ll know what’s driving the results. Otherwise, you’re making decisions based on a pretty limited view of the business.
Shannon: Yeah, which makes me wonder how often SaaS platforms are having these conversations. So if you’ve been with the same payments provider for several years, when was the last time that you sat down and really, truly reviewed the economics of your program?
Michelle: Not just the total volume or revenue. I’d wanna understand what’s changed and whether there are things worth looking at more closely.
Shannon: Yeah, that’s probably a good place to start. And before you can identify opportunities, you really need to know what’s happening with the program that you already have. So let’s talk about some of the things that can affect what a platform earns from payments. So one of those is transaction mix, and I think that’s worth explaining because it’s not necessarily something that every SaaS executive spends a lot of time thinking about.
Michelle: Yeah, it’s really the types of transactions your merchants are processing. Are they primarily debit or credit? Are payments happening in person or online? What do the average transaction amounts look like? Those can affect processing costs.
Shannon: Yeah, and the mix could change quite a bit as the platform grows. So they might start serving larger merchants, or maybe they’ve expanded into another industry, or perhaps they’ve added a new way for customers to pay. So, the payments that they’re processing today may look different from when they were first launched.
Michelle: Which means that economics could be different too, and you might not notice that just by looking at total volume.
Shannon: Yeah. So I think that’s where having a payments partner who can help you really understand the data becomes critical. You know, because I wouldn’t expect a SaaS executive to know every detail about interchange or network fees. But they should be able to get a clear explanation of what’s affecting their costs.
Michelle: Yeah, and whether there’s anything that they could be doing differently. Maybe there are opportunities related to how certain transactions are processed, maybe there aren’t. It depends on the merchants, the transaction mix, and the capabilities available.
Shannon: Yeah, so we recently talked about least cost routing in another episode of Payment Pulse, and that’s one example of an optimization opportunity for certain eligible debit transactions. But it’s not something that applies to every payment, and it’s certainly not the only area that’s worth evaluating.
Michelle: Yeah, so I’d also wanna understand whether any changes would make a meaningful financial difference because identifying an opportunity and deciding if it’s worth pursuing are two different things.
Shannon: Yeah, and that’s where the business decisions start getting a little more complicated. So let’s say that a SaaS platform identifies a way to improve its payments margins. You know, it sounds like it’s an easy decision, but what if making that change requires several months of development work?
Michelle: Yeah. Then I’d wanna know what kind of return we’re expecting because that development time could be spent on something else. And if the financial benefit is relatively small, it might not be the best use of the team’s resources.
Shannon: Yeah, and I think that’s especially true for smaller SaaS platforms that don’t have a large product development team. They may already have a long list of things that their customers are asking for, so any payments improvement has to compete with those priorities.
Michelle: Pricing is another area where you have to be careful. There may be opportunities to improve what the platform earns, but you have to consider what that means for merchants.
Shannon: Yeah, because if you increase what merchants are paying and you make your payments offering less competitive, you know, that’s gonna hurt your adoption. And then you’re potentially working against the growth that you’ve spent a lot of time building.
Michelle: Which is why I wouldn’t look at pricing in isolation. I’d wanna understand what merchants are getting, um, how competitive the offering is, and whether there are other ways to improve the economics.
Shannon: Yeah, and sometimes the best decision may be to just leave something alone. You know, if the expected improvement is small or change creates more work than it’s worth, there may be better places to focus your time and energy.
Michelle: Yeah, and I think that can be hard for companies because when you identify a potential opportunity, you naturally wanna do something with it, but not every opportunity needs to become a project.
Shannon: Yeah. And then there’s also the question of how much of the payments business a SaaS platform wants to manage. So as companies grow, some start looking at different payment models because they want more control over the experience of the economics.
Michelle: But that can also mean taking on more responsibility. You know, becoming a full payment facilitator, for example, involves a very different level of investment and operational responsibility, more so than a referral agreement.
Shannon: Yeah, absolutely. And I think that’s one of the reasons that options like Payfac as a Service are worth digging into. And then you also have the flex framework. We’ve talked about that before, so we’re not gonna get into all those different models today. But the idea is that platforms can evaluate different approaches based on their needs rather than assuming that they all need to follow the same path.
Michelle: Financial upside is only part of that decision. You also have to consider what you’re prepared to manage and what it will cost.
Shannon: Yeah. So whether you’re looking at pricing, processing costs, or your overall payments model, I’d wanna see the full business case before making a change.
Michelle: So we’ve talked quite a bit about processing costs, but there is another part of the economics that can get overlooked, and that’s the work involved in managing the payments program itself.
Shannon: Yeah, and that’s something that we’ve seen from the marketing side and the partner side because there’s a lot more involved in supporting a payments program than simply having the integration available. And I think that’s honestly something that gets overlooked a lot of times.
Merchants need to get onboarded. They have questions. There are bound to be support issues of some type. Merchants have reporting needs. And then of course, there’s just a lot of coordination that’s needed between the teams.
Michelle: As the number of merchants grows, those demands can grow too. So if you’re relying a lot on manual processes, you may find that supporting the program is taking more time than you expected.
Shannon: Yeah. So, I think that’s why merchant onboarding is one area that I would look at. You know, how much work does it take to get a new merchant processing?
Are there steps that could be simplified and are merchants getting stuck somewhere in that process?
Michelle: Yeah, I’d look at what happens after their processing. If a merchant has a funding question or needs help reconciling payments, how easy is it to get the information they need?
Shannon: Because if someone has to go back and forth between different systems or teams to resolve an issue, all of that takes time. And when you’re supporting a growing number of merchants, those little inefficiencies can really add up.
Michelle: Yeah, and it also affects the merchant experience. If payments are supposed to make running their business easier, you don’t want them spending a lot of time tracking down information or resolving avoidable issues.
Shannon: Yeah, and that’s where I’d wanna look at the integration and also the workflows around payments. You know, you can see if there’s different things that could be automated. You know, maybe reporting could be better. And then are there ways to make onboarding and support more efficient?
Michelle: And some of those improvements could benefit both the merchant and the SaaS platform. Merchants spend less time dealing with payments issues, and the platform may be able to support growth without adding as much manual work.
Shannon: Yeah, which is another reason that I wouldn’t judge a payments program solely by what it earns on transactions. You also need to consider what it takes to run it. So we’ve covered a few areas, and I don’t want someone listening to feel like they need to go back and completely overhaul their entire payments program.
If you haven’t reviewed your payments economics recently, a great place to start is just by having a simple conversation with your provider.
Michelle: So, I’d ask them to walk through how the program is performing today. What are we earning? What’s affecting our costs? Have there been any meaningful changes over the past year?
Shannon: And I’d also want to know whether there are opportunities that we haven’t evaluated. And I’m not just talking about a list of things that might be possible. Look for opportunities that actually make sense for your merchant base and your transaction mix.
Michelle: With some indication of what the financial benefit could be. Because if you’re going to dedicate resources to something, you need enough information to make that decision.
Shannon: Yeah, and just make sure you bring the right people into that conversation. So depending on the company, that can be finance, product, or whoever is responsible for the payments relationship. And you want the people who understand the financial side and also the operational impact because they’re both important.
Michelle: Yeah, and I wouldn’t leave out the merchant experience. If you’re considering changes to pricing, onboarding, or the way payments work, you need to think about how those changes will affect your customers.
Shannon: And then something else that I would recommend is doing this type of review regularly. It doesn’t need to be a major project every time, but it’s a chance to look at what’s changed and if your current approach still makes sense or if it doesn’t.
Michelle: Because your business isn’t standing still. You’re adding merchants, changing products, and possibly expanding into new markets or industries, and your payments program should be reviewed as a part of that growth.
Shannon: Yeah, that’s true. And you may find that things are going well, and that can be really useful information too. But at least you’re making decisions based on what the numbers are telling you instead of just assuming that everything is fine because volume is increasing.
Michelle: Of course. So I think the main takeaway is that growing a payments program deserves more than just a quick look at processing volume. There are a lot of things that can affect what a SaaS platform earns, and some of those may change as the business grows.
Shannon: And you don’t need to be a payments expert to start asking better questions. Just understand what you’re earning, what it’s costing you, and whether there are opportunities worth exploring. Your payments provider should be helping you work through all of those questions.
Michelle: And don’t overlook the operational side. Sometimes improving how you manage payments can be just as important as looking at transaction costs.
Shannon: Yeah, so if you’d like to explore ways to improve your embedded payments program, visit xplorpay.com to learn about how we work with SaaS platforms. Thanks for listening today, and we’ll see you next time on Payment Pulse.
FAQs
As a platform grows, its transaction mix, costs, merchant base, and support needs may change. A review can help the business understand what the program contributes and what is driving its results.
Review payments revenue, costs, margins, transaction mix, and the resources required to operate and support the program. These measures can change at different rates.
The types of transactions merchants process can influence costs. The mix may shift as a platform adds merchants, expands into new industries, or supports additional ways to pay.
No. A potential improvement should be weighed against its expected financial benefit, development and operational effort, and possible effect on merchant pricing and adoption.
Consider the work involved in merchant onboarding, support, reporting, reconciliation, and coordination across teams. Manual processes can become more demanding as the merchant base grows.
Ask how the program is performing, what is affecting costs, what has changed over time, and whether there are opportunities that fit your merchant base and transaction mix. Request an estimate of the potential benefit and involve the people responsible for finance, product, payments, and the merchant experience.
Article by Xplor Pay
First published: November 16 2026
Last updated: November 16 2026